Cichocka H., J.Z. Lichański, , Zarys historii retoryki, Warszawa. Foss S.K. Korolko M., , Sztuka retoryki. Perelman Ch., , Imperium retoryki, tł. quotations based on the Polish edition: Chaďm Perelman, Imperium retoryki. Retoryka i argumentacja [Empire of rhetoric. Rhetoric and argumentation]. Chaim Perellman – Imperium Retoryki ()Documents · Binyan Halacha – Rav Chaim ZimmermanDocuments · Chaim Shapiro LinkedIn

Author: Yozshuran Akinolrajas
Country: Haiti
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: History
Published (Last): 26 January 2010
Pages: 118
PDF File Size: 16.73 Mb
ePub File Size: 11.71 Mb
ISBN: 855-3-25042-757-7
Downloads: 12648
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Faugal

Who is responsible for these acts?

There was challenged the division into crimes, misdemeanours and offences, and there was retoryk a division into offences against the foundations of the Soviet system and all other groups of crimes. Encyclopedic guide], Wiedza Powszechna, Warszawa Uniformity of the sources of law The philosopher writes: The audience was additionally manipulated during the trial, particularly by means of misuses in the sphere of such notions as the truth, fact, supposition and value.

Chaïm Perelman | LibraryThing

Judgment was executed the following day. However, in keeping with the requirements of rhetoric art, the use of the judging type by the partici- pants in court proceedings is not per se identical with eris- tic On eristic methods retodyki by Stalinist courts… 13 audience31; in the case of the latter, the argumentation is effective when it is accepted by at least part of it According to Perelman the aim of every argumentation is to encourage retorkyi reinforce the support of the statements sub- mitted to the acceptance of certain auditorium Footnotes based on the Polish edition: Associating one element with another one, we bring them together and we try to find a common denomi- nator for them.


Sloane, New York Further characteristics of the arguments of the Soviet retofyki Further three aspects of the argumentative process, pointed out by Perelman, which in a deformed form were used in the eristic of the Stalinist courts, need to be analysed imperoum.

On eristic methods used by Stalinist courts… 35 would be to develop argumentation without paying attention to the reactions of the interlocutor who obligatorily passes from the role of a passive listener to active participant of the conversation. It is clear that in the rhetorically acceptable court case, the measures applied by the communist prosecutors and judges would discredit the undertaken argumentation.

Chaim Gravitzer Vol. 2

More importantly, however, one of the main objectives of Perelman was the development of the modern theory of legal argumentation, including judicial one.

Just like those who want to win at all costs, they grasp all means, eristics do the same here.

Liniarski was brought to the hearing room on the stretcher. Dionisios from Halikarnas, Hermogenes from Tars.

The Rhetoric of Prudence in Stanisław Herakliusz Lubomirski’s De vanitate consiliorum

It must be added that Schopenhauer distinguished between logic and dialectics, and within the lat- ter he distinguished the eristic dialectic. On the 20th Octo- ber the Polish Supreme Court kept the verdict of the capital punishment in force. Wording from the note sent by W. Help Center Find new research papers in: Arguments which are quasi-logical are the ones which could be understood by means of comparing them with formal thinking, of logical or mathematical cha- racter The philosopher justifies the thesis of a narrow perspective of quasi-logical legal reasoning in the following manner: The criterion of effec- tiveness understood in this way is supplemented by Perel- man with the postulate of openness for criticism in the course of the discourse and with the requirement of tolerance.


In the rhetoric of the Stalinist courts positive values were expressed in a favourable attitude towards the author- ity of Generalissimus, the operations of the Red Army, Marxist philosophy, etc.

The abovementio- ned method was also applied against the Polish commanders of the Home Army.

On eristic methods used by Stalinist courts… 43 argument, can create the most effective propaganda tools Negative or positive values very often indicate favourable or unfavourable attitude in relation to the things … without comparing them to other things According to the philosopher, there is a dan- ger that discourse — authority relation will become inverse- ly proportional. Uwagi o latinitas Lubomirskiego [in: Radbruch writes about the law of the Third Reich: Copyright by University of Warsaw.

At the same time, however, Perelman intended to create a modern and coherent theory of argumen- tation He was born in Warsaw, from where in his family emigrated to Belgium. Students will also develop skills such as: Such a shift, hiding ideolo- gy under the pretext of formal legal thought was for the Sta- linist courts a useful eristic method.

Chaïm Perelman (1912–1984)

LXXI, Book 4p. Stelmach writes that legal argumentation should be conduct- ed in a manner that respects the principles of freedom and equality. During the retoryi students will learn to:.